- Bankruptcy
- Compensation
- Conveyancing & Real Estate
- Crime
- Employment Advice & Disputes
- Family Law
- Wills, Estates & Wealth Protection
- Building & Construction
- Corporate & Commercial
- Insolvency & Restructuring
- Intellectual Property
- Litigation & Dispute Resolution
- Planning, Environment & Local Government
- Property & Water
- Taxation & Duties
- Workplace Relations, Employment and Safety
Other - Under $30,000
Apart from damage to motor vehicles, most small property claims are consumer claims - they arise out of the purchase of defective goods or as a result of poor service.
In NSW this is covered by the Consumer Claims Act and there is similar legislation in other states. This legislation applies to consumers who are basically people or private companies who have been supplied with goods or services.
In relation to the supply of goods, there are provisions in the NSW Sale of Goods Act which you can rely upon. For example, the Act says that the goods must be fit for the purpose for which they have been provided and they must be of "merchantable quality".
If goods or services have been supplied by a company, there are many provisions in the Australian Trade Practices Act which give you rights. If the goods or services have been supplied by an individual or a partnership then there are many provisions in the NSW Fair Trading Act which will be of assistance.
Once again, you have to be careful in incurring legal costs if the value of the damaged item is not great. There is no point in consulting a lawyer at $250 per hour about a defective iron which cost $70.
What our clients say
I am still in disbelief [regarding my award of compensation]. Wow!
Thank you so much for your assistance, hard work and understanding.
Warmest regards,
LC

Recent Successes
In the course of the proceedings for damages against the doctor, the client sought a declaration from the workers compensation insurer that payments made to him pursuant to the Act were not repayable pursuant to Section 151Z.
The workers compensation insurer advised us that they considered they had a right of recovery for all weekly compensation benefits and medical expenses paid pursuant to Section 151Z (1) (d) of the Act and would be pursuing recovery of these.
In reply we wrote to the insurer and advised there have been a series of Court of Appeal decisions which have found that in this situation Section 151Z (1) (d) does not operate to allow the workers compensation insurer to recover the payments it has made.
In Hood Constructions Pty Limited v Nicholas [1987] NSWLR 60 the court stated that the injury caused by the medical treatment was not "an injury for which compensation is payable" within the meaning of Section 151Z, notwithstanding the fact that the surgery was undertaken to remedy an injury sustained in the court of employment. The court went on to find that the worker's damages against the doctor were to be reduced to take into account the compensation payments already received.
This was confirmed in the matter of Rooty Hill Medical Centre Pty Limited v Gunther [2002] NSWCA 60. The court of appeal confirmed that Section 151Z of the Workers Compensation Act did not apply and the plaintiff’s damages had to be reduced to give effect to the overriding intention of parliament that a worker should not be entitled to both compensation and damages.
The workers compensation insurer then conceded that Section 151Z did not apply in this case and they would not be pursuing any recovery from our client. This was important as we were then able to advise our client on his likely damages if he was successful in the claim.

The Consumer Trader and Tenancy Tribunal
Fortunately under the Consumer Claims Act there is provision for consumer claims up to $30,000 to be handled in quite an informal manner by a member of the Consumer Trader and Tenancy Tribunal (CTTT). The good thing about going through the CTTT is that you can do it yourself, you don't need a lawyer. And it's inexpensive. It costs less than $100 to lodge an application and there are no more fees.The CTTT will try to resolve your dispute through conciliation, where you and the other party sit down to talk about the issues and try to reach an agreement. If you can’t, there is an informal hearing before a Tribunal Member. You both get to give evidence and ask each other questions, then the Member makes a decision. Known as an ‘Order’, this is the written decision about money that must be paid, or work that must be completed.
In some situations you might choose to have one of our lawyers help you prepare for the hearing, or attend with you (if the amount involved is over $10,000), but this is at your own cost.
The NSW Office of Fair Trading
The Fair Trading website (www.fairtrading.nsw.gov.au) has some useful tips for protecting yourself against scams, such as ways to ensure your tradesperson is registered, asking for a receipt and warranty, and not paying cash up front.In The Community
Stacks Blog
Latest News
Stacks TV
Make an enquiry
| Name: | * |
| Contact Number: | * |
| Email: | * |
| Postcode: | * |
| Area Of Law: |
|
|
Enquiry:
|
|
|
|
|
Enter your postcode to find your nearest specialist.
eg 1234
Nearest Specialists
Home | About Us | Locations | People | Expertise | Careers | Community | Latest News | Contact Us | Link Exchange

