Superannuation and total and permanent disability (TPD) lawyers and claims

Commonly asked questions about TPD claims:

There is nothing to stop you making a claim for a disability benefit under your superannuation scheme without the assistance of a lawyer. However, if the claim is disputed by the insurer then you will need legal assistance. Insurance companies are very experienced at disputing these claims and their claims officers are backed by lawyers who do nothing else but this type of work. You would be very brave to take them on without legal assistance from someone who specialises in this area.

Stacks compensation lawyers have considerable experience in pursuing claims for disability benefits because it is not unusual for accident victims to also have rights under their compulsory superannuation scheme.

A very typical test under these insurance policies is that you are entitled to a disability benefit for any period during which ‘you are not capable of earning income, by way of personal exertion from any occupation for which you are reasonably suited by reason of education, training or experience’.

Sometimes the test will be expressed this way: ‘You are not capable of earning two thirds or more of your average monthly income, by way of personal exertion.’ This is a much more reasonable test because it would be a bit unfair to say to a specialist doctor, who was disabled in an accident, that he or she couldn’t recover disability benefits because he or she was capable of serving petrol in a service station.

Either way, the test is still quite vague. Opinions can obviously vary about the work for which ‘you are reasonably suited by reason of education, training or experience’.

Any death or disability benefit available under your superannuation scheme will be available under a policy issued by an insurance company. The insurance company ultimately makes the decision about your eligibility for a TPD claim.

Insurance companies typically take a hard line in relation to these claims because once someone is entitled to a disability benefit the insurer is concerned that they may get used to an idle life and show no interest in getting back to work.

Once you make a claim for a disability benefit, the insurer will normally refer you to a medical specialist and these tend to be medical specialists who take a rather hard approach. If the specialist can identify some work which you are capable of doing, this will justify the insurer in refusing the disability benefit and the specialist is likely to find that more cases are referred to him or her by the insurer.

The fact that the insurer refuses your claim on the basis of their doctor’s report is not the end of the matter. We can refer you to a specialist with a reputation for being more even-handed in these matters, and if that specialist concludes that you are not ‘fit for work for which you are reasonably suited by reason of education and training or experience’, then we can commence legal proceedings so that an independent judge can decide if the insurer was reasonable in refusing your claim for a disability benefit.

Once legal proceedings have been commenced, it is not unusual for these claims to be settled on a compromise basis. In fact, if there is a genuine dispute between opposing medical specialists, these claims normally are settled. Sometimes our medical evidence is so strong that we advise you not to compromise at all, in which case the matter may well proceed to a hearing – unless the insurer gives up, as they sometimes do.

The time limits which apply to personal injury claims do not apply to the claims for a death or disability benefit under a superannuation scheme. Unless there is some specific time restriction to make a claim within the superannuation policy itself, you can make a claim within 6 years of your right commencing. As a claim for disability may be a continuing claim, as long as you remain disabled you can claim under the policy and if you cease to be disabled you can claim benefits for the previous 6 years – subject of course to any particular clause in the policy.

Our experts



Dog attack in Sydney park costs owner $50,000
19 May 2022
Toddler left with severe facial injuries after dog attack in Sydney park It was...
Read More
Impacts of climate change on our children – is there a duty of care?
12 May 2022
In May 2021, in what was described as a worldwide landmark judgment, the Federal...
Read More
Allianz and AWP fined $1.5 million for misleading sale of travel insurance
03 Mar 2022
Insurance companies were issued a strong warning after the Federal Court fined ...
Read More
Failure to meet duty of care to employees costs employer $120,000 for rolled ankle
15 Feb 2022
Sometimes it’s much wiser to agree to a worker’s reasonable request than ...
Read More
PIAC report identifies pattern of mental health discrimination in insurance industry
09 Feb 2022
A ten year study of the insurance industry’s treatment of people has found ...
Read More
Can you claim workers compensation for Covid if you’re infected at work?
26 Oct 2021
With the coronavirus lockdown coming to an end, many employers and building ...
Read More
Does a smack on the bottom constitute common assault?
14 Oct 2021
Annabel Bassil was managing a Sydney bar when a man she didn’t know smacked ...
Read More
Can a dying declaration be admitted in evidence?
01 Sep 2021
A man is shot and lies dying on the floor in a pool of blood. He’s discovered ...
Read More
Domestic coercive control could soon be criminal in Australia
26 Aug 2021
Domestic abuse in the form of coercive control could soon be a criminal act ...
Read More
Sexual consent law reform in NSW: a nod’s as good as a wink on a blind date
21 Jul 2021
In May 2021 the Attorney-General Mark Speakman announced the reform of sexual ...
Read More
Proposed child abuse compensation laws in NSW give survivors some hope of justice
13 Jul 2021
Survivors of institutional child abuse will be able to overturn unfair ...
Read More
Government cannot ignore impact of climate change on children when approving coal mine expansion
17 Jun 2021
In what has been hailed as a worldwide landmark judgement, in May 2021 the ...
Read More

Why Stacks

No Win No Fee
If we don’t achieve a successful outcome for you then we won’t charge you any fees. For full disclosure about this offer, see here
First consultation free
Contact us today and together we can help you work out what your next steps might be... in confidence, at no cost and with no obligation
Hundreds of successful claims every year
Our team of personal injury lawyers are experts in this field of law (many are Accredited Specialists)
Real client care
Genuine care for clients has been at the core of our practice since the first office was opened by ER Stack on the NSW Mid-North Coast in 1931
Over 25 local offices
Our local offices are owned and operated by friendly, local professionals, who are proud and active members of the communities they serve
Practical advice not legalese
We provide clear, practical advice, in plain English, so that you can make decisions with confidence

More about our promises

Get help now

It's easy to get help, just tell us your story and we'll help you understand all your options. If you’d like us to help, we’ll agree exactly the work you'd like us to do up front so that you can be certain about our costs.

Your enquiry is completely confidential.

Complete the form and one of our experts will get back to you within 24 hours.

Reach out

Fill out this form and one of our local law professionals will be in contact

By submitting this form you agree to the terms of our Privacy policy